Quest: A profitable deal[翻译中，未整理]

i think nathan the fisherman is by far the best choice ..
You get 15 edible crayfish ,
2 you need for a quest when you get relic seeker rep 200 and th rest you can sell
Think giving it to the elder gives some city rep but still i would go for fisherman

I think the 2 best choices are to either take the poison or pay him for the ring and return it to Magdalena